HR's Struggle to Find Successors

By David Shadovitz 就像古语说的一样，鞋匠的孩子没鞋穿。尽管HR人员的主要职责就是为企业发掘人才，但据调查显示以及相关专家分析，HR人员在为企业搜寻适合的CEO,CFO接班人上成绩斐然，然而却疏于发掘优秀的HR接班人。

Despite HR's role as the steward of talent management and development, a recent study suggests that HR leaders are doing a far better job developing CEO and CFO successors internally than their own HR successors. A recent study of Fortune 500 companies by Patrick Wright, a professor at Cornell University's School of Industrial and Labor Relations and dean of the school's Center for Advanced Human Resource Studies, found that only 36 percent of CHROs were internally groomed, compared to 54 percent of chief financial officers and 65 percent of chief executive officers. When I presented on the topic of CHRO succession, I would regularly get asked how the chief HR officer differed from other C-suite jobs, says Wright. So this year, for the first time, we decided to add questions on CEO and CFO succession to the study. The findings were reported last month in a blog post on the HR Policy Association website. Wright says he wasn't surprised by the 36-percent figure, since it was consistent with prior Cornell/CAHRS Chief HR Officer surveys. But he was surprised to see that CFOs and CEOs were having much better success than their HR colleagues. The apparent neglect by HR leaders of HR succession plans, Wright says, is reminiscent of the tale of the cobbler's children, who went shoeless because the cobbler was so busy making shoes for his customers. I find it surprising that the function in charge of leadership development is worse, far worse, at developing its own leaders than finance, Wright says. It suggests something is seriously wrong with the function. Wright says he would like to see more HR leaders embrace the attitude of retired General Electric Co. chief HR officer Bill Conaty, who once said he would have felt he had failed in his job if he had retired before developing his own successor. A few factors could be at play here, experts say. Wright believes some HR executives may be unwilling to take the risk of giving potential successors the exposure they need to be considered for the top post. Some HR leaders, like Eva Sage-Gavin of the Gap, make a great effort to bring ... direct reports into board meetings ... so they can be exposed to the dynamics of what happens at that level, Wright says. But other HR leaders view that as far too risky, fearing that if that person screws up it would reflect badly on them. If you want to develop successors, he says, I think it's incumbent on you to get your people in front of the board and get them acclimated to the dynamics of what happens in the board meeting. Susan Meisinger, an author, speaker and consultant who writes HREOnlineTM's HR Leadership column, believes the nature of conversation may be another reason. HR succession issues are more difficult, Meisinger says, because much of the contact between HR and the CEO touches on confidential topics such as performance and compensation. That makes it tougher for HR leaders to give potential successors the kind of exposure they need, as opposed to CEO conversations with finance or marketing leaders, which tend to be much more numbers oriented and less sensitive. Like Wright, Dave Ulrich, a professor at the University of Michigan's Ross School of Business and a partner at the RBL Group in Provo, Utah, agrees the profession could do a better job developing the next generation of leaders. But he also believes there are good reasons CHROs are not having the same success finding internal talent as their CEO and CFO colleagues. There's a much wider variance in terms of what's expected of an HR leader than other functions such as finance, Ulrich says. As senior business leaders see the changing potential of HR to deliver value, they want to raise the bar on HR, he says. They want future HR leaders who can do the basics at a world-class level. But they also want HR professionals who can become true strategic partners who can contribute to their business' success. Nowadays, Ulrich says, CEOs are looking for more in their HR professionals ... . They want something different from their CHROs. And with these increased expectations, he says, the pool of candidates is smaller. In contrast, Ulrich says, the variance for finance is far less, since we know what's expected of the CFO. The good news, he says, is that the bar for HR is continuing to be raised, adding that HR leaders should be able to reduce the variance as expectations become clearer. In the meantime, other experts say, HR leaders should continue to focus on ways to strengthen their own bench strength. Wright believes HR leaders need to improve the assessments they're performing on their own talent and put potential successors in situations that shed light on their competencies. Specifically, Wright says, potential successors should be given experience in two key areas: talent management and executive compensation. These are kinds of experiences that will broaden them as potential successors, particularly as the HR role is defined today. 管理新知 您可能感兴趣的文章 数据告诉你，每次只专注一个任务 2016-08-16 There Are People in Your Shiny Objects 2014-01-15 The

10 Best Paying Jobs You Can Get Without a College Degree 2011-08-23 最近文章 TEST 2018年01月15日 嫖娼被抓不属无故旷工，公司解雇赔4万！（法院判决） 2018年01月15日 如何判断你是否具有HRBP胜任力？

2018年01月15日 阿里为什么不去清华招人？

2018年01月15日 因利益冲突，Facebook COO和Twitter CEO退出迪士尼董事会 2018年01月15日 热门文章 嫖娼被抓不属无故旷工，公司解雇赔4万！（法院判决） 2018年01月15日 如何判断你是否具有HRBP胜任力？

2018年01月15日 阿里为什么不去清华招人？

2018年01月15日 2017年度职场出差行程调查，出差最多的居然是他们！！

2018年01月12日 员工在自己QQ空间评论HR经理吃屎，可辞退他吗？

2018年01月11日 扫一扫 加微信【已隐去】 关于沙龙 顾问委员 广告推广 隐私安全 联系我们 申请vip会员 支付方式 市场合作或广告投放 电话：【电话已隐去】 邮件：【邮箱已隐去】 在线QQ【已隐去】 VIP会员 企业VIP会员 机构VIP会员 广告刊例 商务合作 Follow HRSalon